Illegally downloading music: to many it seems like second
nature. If one hears a song and likes it, they download it illegally. Of course any
act with the word ‘illegal’ in it probably has it there for a good reason. Hard
drugs are illegal, human trafficking is illegal, but for some reason many
people do not take illegal downloading of music as serious as others mentioned
and rightly so. Many people often probably say, “I am not hurting anyone, how
is this bad?” “I just want this one song, I don’t want the whole album,” and of
course the most famous of them all, “They (music artists) are already rich
enough, I’m poor (in some sense) why should I give them any more money?” Note
the one word that is brought up in every one of those questions: I.
Perhaps what people who say these types of phrases need to
do is to make the phrases plural and think about the consequences then. “We are
not hurting anyone, how is this bad?” “We just want one song, we don’t want the
whole album,” “They are already rich enough, we’re poor why should we give them
any more money.” This is what Kant asks us to think about whilst looking
through the lenses of his philosophical idea called the Categorical Imperative.
In short, the Categorical Imperative asks us to make a
decision about an action based upon the idea of what if everybody did the action
we are considering to do.The truth is, especially when it comes to illegally
downloading music, everyone has to look at this topic through the categorical
imperative because that is what almost happening: almost. Many people have, and
continue to download music illegally, but not everybody; Kant asks if everybody
does it. Would anyone win? I believe the answer is no. No because if everybody
stole artist’s music, they would not be able to continue making their music, nor
would they able to begin making quality sounding music because they would not
be able to afford the cost of recording and re-recording music, or at least the
artists who are trying to make it big. For that matter, if artist’s music was
stolen by everybody, no artists would be able to make it big, and the number of
people making quality music would go down substantially.
Therefore, it is not good to illegally download music, even
if it is from an extremely wealthy artist, because in the end it will affect the
individual who illegally downloads music because they are hacking away at the
very big trunk of the music industry tree, cutting off the green nutrients
which feed the artists ability to make music and one day, maybe, this tree
could fall.